The Mosquito and The Bear - Hong Kong's Democrats Taking on China

"You can never imagine how cruel our police officers are. If they sent an order to clear the ground, I'm sure there would be blood." Chen, who is posted at one of several resource centres around the protest site, is not optimistic. In normal life, he works at the police station (in administration)  so has some working knowledge of the people who may force an end to the occupation. He is eloquent, rational and worried, but he is resilient: "I guess we'll just have to wait for the old generation to go to hell and then maybe we'll be civilised enough for democracy."

Each of the protesters that I had the pleasure of talking to were intelligent and calm. Their inspiration comes from the Ghandis and Martin Luther Kings of the world. "I hope it remains peaceful." I said  to Damon, a spectacled man in his mid 20's. He is uncompromising in his certainty, "We will keep it peaceful. If they send army here, we'll still be peaceful - that's our promise.' I believe him, but with the spectre of the Tienanmen massacre hanging , a quarter of a century old, no one can be sure that they trust the Chinese Government to practice the same restraint.


Hong Kong Govt. HQ
The protesters have been occupying three sites around Hong Kong for over a month. My visit was to Admiralty, the largest site, where the tent city surrounds two sides of government headquarters - a monolithic, oppressive building, well suited to its role. There is an impressive infrastructure already in place with recycling centres and first aid stands dotted around at various points among the tents. Resource centres doling out sleeping bags, tents, coats and snacks donated by well wishers and supporters, largely from the older sections of society. Those who want to help but whose responsibilities tie them down.

There is a study centre stocked with tables and chairs quickly flung together by a local carpenter. Steven was at the front desk and welcomed me in, measuring his reasons for participation carefully. He was also pessimistic about their chances, realistic about the Chinese government. Uncertain but hopeful. "Are you nervous?" I asked, "Maybe if I was on my own I would be nervous, but together I'm not scared." I wandered into the study area, "Please don't take pictures inside," he called after me, "we want to protect the students." The tarpaulin structure was full and segregated into different subject areas. There is wifi.

The level of organisation is impressive - particularly considering that the movement is largely headless (or it has too many). There is no one group or person with enough support to make unilateral decisions. This may be its Achilles heel. It seemed as though almost everyone I spoke to was an individual - fighting for democracy, but not for any particular party or group.

Public opinion is turning against the occupation (if not the fight) because of the disruption it is
A recycling centre
causing. There are arguments that maybe the occupation should shift out of the way to retain the support of the public. The government seems to be playing a waiting game - let the protesters erode their own support through inactivity and disruption. It seems to be working, but there is no decision making body to push through a  tactical change, just several more or less powerful groups acting largely independently for a common cause. Several people expressed their dissatisfaction at the occupation not actually doing anything at the moment, not being productive.

I spoke to the CEO of the Democratic Party, Lam Cheuk-Hung, who was considered and resigned to the struggle. His party has taken a back seat to the student organisations but he believes that they should remain in place until concessions are proposed. His view is that there is no other alternative. That they must wait it out, come what may.

The first line of defence
At the furthest reach of the site, four slight teenagers were the first line of defence. It's almost laughable when you see them and compare them to the might of China. This is bravery. It is naive, maybe stupid, but it is courageous. "This is our last stand. If we leave we have nothing to bargain with." They would stay over a year if it was necessary.

So would Susan, an architect who was caught up in the tear gas attack that greeted the occupation in its early days. She fled because she was terrified. They fired the tear gas, but the protesters could see that the police were carrying guns. "I was scared, I did not know what they would do, so I left." That is absolutely understandable. She came back and has been sleeping in a tent at night and travelling to work every morning. There are no showers. She is bedding in for the long haul, though not optimistic. She is however, impressed with her countrymen. "You've come here at the right time," she said, "isn't it amazing that its so peaceful?"

A fourteen year old volunteer
It is. Honestly it was an honour to have a chance to speak to the protesters, with whom it seems democracy could actually be trusted - unlike the madness of the US or British people's apathy and disinterest. Thomas, who owns a factory on the mainland which makes handbags for Accessorize and ships them to Britain, spoke of his long standing belief that the young people of Hong Kong were selfish and thoughtless. This middle aged man, typically dismissive of youth, has had his mind totally changed. "I was wrong." He said. Now he spends his free time at the protests, giving support to students. His organisation is consciously there to make sure there are parental figures, just in case they're needed.

The youngest protester I spoke to was a fourteen year old boy, he did not speak a lot of English, but was a volunteer and seemed to be protesting with his grandfather. It is a cross generational movement led by students and there is a feeling of great respect and togetherness at the protest site.

Speaking to a policeman at the edge of the protest, it was clear that he agreed with their motivations. In what he made sure to mention was his personal view, he said, "I can support their desire for democracy but they are going about it the wrong way." He suggested that they move to Victoria Park, but it seems to me that without the disruption, they would make less noise and lose some bargaining power. I asked if he would fire tear gas if he was ordered to. He fumbled a response about different countries having different methods in situations like this, before saying that if the order came down to clear the protest, he would follow orders and do what it takes.

We will probably see what it takes in the coming weeks. For now, the protesters in Admiralty, in the shadow of government headquarters seem realistic but resigned; together. They are not blind to the dangers of their struggle. I can only respect them and wish them the best. I left inspired but worried for their future. Chen summed up the general feeling in the air: "I hope we are doing something. We don't think this will end well, we just hope it won't end ugly."